Why OpenID will never work

by Jason Preston on March 18, 2008

If you think any of this gibberish looks interesting, you should poke around and subscribe to my RSS feed to keep up with new content.

I currently use Disqus as the comment system on this blog, and they made a blog post today about their beta 2 updates. One of the ones that caught my eye was that they’re supporting OpenID and “making the registration process easier.”

This is a good thing since I know someone who managed to make their PASSWORD their USERNAME. Hmmm…that level of confusion doesn’t encourage users to sign up.

But here’s the thing about OpenID: the concept, as far as I understand it, is so very essential. And the implementation is total crap. It will never work, and here’s why:

  1. Go to www.OpendID.com. There’s nothing there. If you’re serious you buy the domain.
  2. If you google it and find out it’s OpenID.net, it’s still freaking hard to “get one.”

If OpenID really means business, they need to buy OpenID.com and set up a Google-esque home page where the user has a CLEAR “call-to-action.”

In other words, I want to go to OpenID and be prompted:

—————-
“do you have a login with any of the following sites?” [dropdown box]

Login below:

If not, create your OpenID here:

[box]

[password box]
—————–

Currently, it’s just too byzantine.

Tagtastic: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • ThisNext
  • Wists
  • Netscape
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • TailRank
  • Technorati